Was Thomas Shelby a Communist?
Thomas Shelby, a fictional character from the popular British TV series “Peaky Blinders,” has been a subject of much debate and speculation. One of the most intriguing questions that have emerged is whether Thomas Shelby was a communist. This article aims to explore this topic and delve into the evidence that supports or refutes this claim.
Background on Thomas Shelby
Thomas Shelby, portrayed by Cillian Murphy, is the leader of the Shelby crime family in Birmingham, England, during the post-World War I era. The series, created by Steven Knight, showcases the rise and fall of the Shelby family as they navigate the complexities of post-war Britain. Thomas Shelby is depicted as a charismatic, intelligent, and ruthless individual who is willing to do whatever it takes to protect his family and their interests.
Speculation on Shelby’s Communist leanings
The question of whether Thomas Shelby was a communist primarily arises from his interactions with political figures and his actions during the series. Some viewers have noted that Shelby seems to have a strong sense of justice and a desire to fight against the corrupt establishment. This has led to speculation that he might have communist sympathies.
One of the key pieces of evidence that some viewers point to is Shelby’s association with a character named Arthur Cutler, who is portrayed as a communist. Throughout the series, there are instances where Shelby appears to support Cutler’s cause, such as when he helps Cutler in a labor dispute. This has led some to believe that Shelby might have communist leanings himself.
Analysis of Shelby’s actions and beliefs
While there is some evidence that suggests Shelby might have communist sympathies, it is important to analyze his actions and beliefs in the context of the series. Throughout “Peaky Blinders,” Shelby is shown to be primarily motivated by protecting his family and their interests. While he may have a strong sense of justice, it is not clear that he has a genuine commitment to communist ideology.
Furthermore, Shelby’s association with Arthur Cutler does not necessarily mean that he shares the same beliefs. In the series, Shelby often uses Cutler’s influence to further his own goals, rather than genuinely adopting communist principles. This suggests that Shelby’s actions may be more opportunistic than ideological.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while there is some evidence that suggests Thomas Shelby might have communist sympathies, it is not clear that he was a communist in the true sense of the word. The series “Peaky Blinders” portrays Shelby as a complex character whose actions are primarily driven by his desire to protect his family and their interests. While he may have moments of idealism and a sense of justice, it is difficult to say that he was a communist. Ultimately, the question of whether Thomas Shelby was a communist remains a topic of debate and speculation among fans of the series.
